This Month in Design007 Magazine: Dear Designers—Please Include a Sanity Check


Reading time ( words)

No discussion about fab notes and documentation would be complete without the insight from DownStream Technologies. DownStream has spent 18 years developing tools to help PCB designers provide more accurate, complete data packages to the fabricator. We recently asked Rick Almeida, DownStream co-founder, and Technical Sales Manager Ray Fugitt to discuss why so many fabricators are still receiving (and correcting) inaccurate and incomplete data from their customers. And if fabricators and designers are content with this current process, is it really a problem after all?

Andy Shaughnessy: It’s great to speak with you both, even by conference call. Can you tell us about some of the biggest problems that fabricators have to deal with, as far as data from their customers?

Rick Almeida: Ray’s experience is actually working for fabricators, so he’d have a pretty good technical knowledge of what some of the issues are. But from what we see as a company, dealing with this on a day-to-day basis, is that some of the problems are in a couple of different areas. One is there’s a myriad of data files that get handed off. The market, in general, is still Gerber-centric and not so much single manufacturing file-centric. Because of that, you have a lot of different data files and documentation to tell you how to use those data files, which creates issues. When you have so many different data files, you run into the issue of if all the data files are there and correct. Does the design itself line up with what the manufacturer is asking you to build? Those are the common things that we see people having problems with. Ray, do you want to add anything to that?

Ray_Fugitt.jpgRay Fugitt: One of the biggest ones we see, and especially since I’m in tech support now, is bad data out of the CAD systems. There is this thought throughout the industry that the CAD systems don’t put out bad data, but we see it every day.

Barry Matties: Why are they getting bad data out of the CAD system?

Fugitt: I have examples. Things like—I’ll throw the term out there, and you can put yourself to sleep Googling it—“self-intersecting polygons.”

Almeida: It’s just a conversion of the intelligent design into unintelligent Gerber files, and what that entails to drive a machine, as opposed to screen graphics.

Fugitt: We’re doing a translation, and just to carry that one just a little bit further is it’s illegal, per the Gerber spec, to get all the CAD system’s output and know how you can go any further with that.

Almeida: It always goes back to that common issue between design systems and manufacturing systems. This is at the end of the process, and it’s where the smallest amount of R&D is spent on the manufacturing side of the design tools. And that’s a large reason why people are still gravitating toward Gerber files, as opposed to an ODB++ or an IPC-2581 file; they just don’t have that experience.

To read this entire interview, which appeared in the August 2020 issue of Design007 Magazine, click here.

Share




Suggested Items

Master the Art of Communication With Manufacturers

06/30/2022 | Kyle Burk, KBJ Engineering
As mentioned in the May issue of Design007 Magazine, design is performed, at times, in a vacuum. But it doesn’t have to be that way. Whenever circumstances allow, design should be performed by communicating with all stakeholders throughout the design process, hence the emphasis on the word with in DWM. Communication can occur through personal correspondence such as email and voice conversations or through more formal design meetings—in person or through videoconferencing. No matter which means of communication you prefer, it’s important to communicate early and often with stakeholders involved in the downstream processes as you bring your project to realization.

Altimade Puts Designers and Manufacturers Together

06/24/2022 | Andy Shaughnessy, Design007 Magazine
Despite all of the talk about the need for communication between designers and manufacturers, many PCB designers still do not talk with their manufacturers for a variety of reasons. Altium and MacroFab aim to change this dynamic. In this interview, Ted Pawela, chief ecosystem officer of Altium and head of Altium’s Nexar Business Unit, and MacroFab CEO Misha Govshteyn, discuss the new Altimade manufacturing service that Altium is introducing in partnership with MacroFab. Ted and Misha provide an overview of the Altimade process, how it links designers to fabricators, assembly providers, and component distributors, and they explain how it could pave the way for true design with manufacturing, or DWM.

The Survey Said: Why Don’t You Know Your Fabricator?

06/23/2022 | I-Connect007 Editorial Team
When we want to find out what challenges our readers are facing, we just ask. And they don’t mind sharing—the good, the bad, and the ugly. In a recent survey, we asked our PCB designer readers, “Why don’t you know who is going to manufacture your boards?” Here are some of more interesting replies we received, edited slightly for clarity. Do you see yourself in these replies?



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.