ROSE – What Does the Data Mean and When Is It Useful?


Reading time ( words)

ROSE (Resistivity Of Solvents Extracted) testing was developed in the 1960s as a quality assurance and process monitoring method and is still regularly used today. Unfortunately, profound changes in the processes and materials used in the electronic assembly industry have a significant impact on the usefulness of the test. This article will discuss what ROSE test results really mean and when they are—and more importantly, are not—useful.

What does the data mean?

ROSE testing is performed by submerging an entire electronic assembly into a solution of DI water and IPA (isopropyl alcohol). Results are given as µg/cm2 of NaCl equivalence and represents the amount of solulizable ionic contamination present on the entire assembly. The reading is derived by simply measuring the resisitivity of the solution over time; the test does not identify specific ions present.

Limitations in this test method have been realized as many current flux residues are not particularyly soluble in the test solution (the test was developed for wave-soldered through hole hardware soldered with RMA fluxes). Additionally, low component clearances make it difficult to remove and detect trapped ionic contamination.

When is it useful?

Depending on the complexity of the assembly and the materials used, the ROSE test method can still be a reasonably effective process monitoring tool. With an established baseline in place, ROSE testing can provide useful feedback if a process errata results in a change in cleanliness.

Is ROSE testing a good predictor of reliability?

Unfortunately, ROSE testing is not (and in our opinion, never really was) a good predictor of product reliability. With shrinking components and increased density, decreasing pitches, and ever expanding presence of high-sensitivity circuits, cleanliness is more important now than it has ever been. Foresite routinely links field failures to small pockets of localized contamination (e.g. no-clean flux is not fully heat-activated after wicking under a selective solder pallet) which simply can not be detected by fully submerging the assembly and averaging the results over the entire surface area of the board.

ROSE testing can still be useful in a limited manner as a process monitoring tool, but relying on a test developed over fifty years ago for determining cleanliness of wave-soldered through hole boards processed with RMA flux to predict reliability of current electronic assemblies is asking for trouble.

Share




Suggested Items

Passing the Test With SMTA’s Rob Boguski

09/14/2022 | Andy Shaughnessy, I-Connect007
I recently spoke with Rob Boguski, president of Fremont, California-based Datest and an SMTA vice president and board member. Rob explained why today’s test customers are asking for more information than the traditional pass/fail, offers a preview of SMTA International, and gives an update on SMTA’s planning strategy for the next five years.

Four Silver Linings in the Stormy Clouds of Pandemic, Supply Chain, and Inflation

09/14/2022 | Dr. Ronald C. Lasky, Indium Corp.
It may be difficult to see any bright spots in the current and recent economic situation. We have all experienced the devastation of the pandemic, supply chain issues, and most recently, inflation. However, as a senior technologist for an international materials supplier (Indium Corporation) and a professor of engineering at an Ivy League research university (Dartmouth College), I offer these four silver linings for those of us in the electronics industry.

Solder Paste Printing and Optimizations for Interconnecting Back Contact Cells

07/26/2022 | Narahari S Pujari and Krithika PM, MacDermid Alpha Electronics Solutions
The interdigitated back contact (IBC) is one of the methods to achieve rear contact solar cell interconnection. The contact and interconnection via rear side theoretically achieve higher efficiency by moving all the front contact grids to the rear side of the device. This results in all interconnection structures being located behind the cells, which brings two main advantages. First, there is no frontside shading of the cell by the interconnection ribbons, thus eliminating the need for trading off series resistance, losses for shading losses when using larger interconnection ribbons. Second, a more homogeneous looking frontside of the solar module enhances the aesthetics.



Copyright © 2022 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.